On Monday, the Washington Post reported that a former investment manager with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has filed a whistleblower complaint with the … A inside whistle blower has alleged the Mormon Church misled members on how a $100 billion investment fund was used. deductible. Whistleblower Alleges $100 Billion Secret Stockpile By Mormon Church. Of all the experts I have communicated with Professor Brunson is the one with most serious concerns about Ensign. I probably oversimplified the Nielsens' argument, which Mr. Nielsen characterized on the phone as an inadvertent straw-man argument. My difference with them is in the expectation that there is a role for the IRS here given the current state of the law. The whistleblower. The 990-T that is in Mr. Nielsen’s document package was signed by the preparer the day before it was due. The whistleblower complaint noted that David had concerns about some practices at EPA since 2013 and voiced some of those … In just over 20 years, Ensign amassed $100 billion. If it wants to hoard money that's fine, but its investment income should be taxed just as every other individual or corporation's investment income is taxed. Here is our email exchange in interview format: Reilly - Suppose there was no separate tax exempt involved. A former employee of the Church’s non-profit investment firm, Ensign Peak Advisors, has complained to the IRS. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. Life is more complicated now, but it's real and we're still happy. When it comes to churches, LDS may be sui generis in that regard. A whistleblower alleges in the complaint, filed with the IRS, that billions of dollars collected in tithes mandatory donations by members were invested in an investment arm of the church Ensign Peak Advisors but in 22 years, has not been distributed to charitable causes in accordance with IRS rules, according to a report in the Washington Post. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. I have written about that here, here and here. I like the “Middle Road” approach to this story taken by Bishop Bill over on Wheat & Tares last Sunday. A church-owned ‘anti-bank’ Consider what happened in … In some sense I think what we are witnessing is the asking and answering of different questions. Republican Demands For Covid Relief Forced Some Bizarre Choices, Congress Takes Lead On PPP In New Stimulus Bill, Defying Treasury, Stimulus Payments, Paycheck Protection Program Expense Deductibility Headline Tax Changes In Latest Covid Relief Package, Here’s A Look At What’s In The Massive Covid-Response Stimulus Bill, Covid Relief Bill — Significant Tax Relief For Individuals And Businesses, Loren Ponds Talks Secrets To Success And Writing Tax Reform, All You Need To Know About Round Two Of Covid-Related Stimulus Checks. According to the National Whistleblower Center, IRS 211 claims — under which the accusations made against Ensign Peak Advisors fall — are signed under oath and penalty of perjury. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you … sltrib.com © 1996-2020 The Salt Lake Tribune. I think they do and still think so..... Now, Ensign will almost surely argue that it is an integral part of the church. Professor Hackney pointed me to Revenue Procedure 96-10 which indicates the sort of auxiliary organizations that share in the blessings of the church’s exemption from filing Form 990. I asked Professor Brunson about that. We’ll see how that goes. Sources confirm that David’s job at EPA became complicated as his wife and children left the LDS Church. Until September 2019, Nielsen had been a senior portfolio manager for the Mormon-church run investment non-profit, Ensign Peak Advisors. The whistleblower is a Mormon who worked for the church until September. In his letter, he asked the IRS to remove Ensign Peak’s tax-exempt status and compel it … The church also spends a significant amount on philanthropic ventures. But you should know how much you gave their (Ensign Peak Advisors) slush fund since the COP (Corporation of the President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) created it … Reilly - It seems like the commensurate thing would be based on a charity that was formed to raise and invest to support the religion in general and never spent anything. Lars Nielsen, who provided the documents to reporters, said members deserve an apology from church leaders and the investment company. His other comment to me really gets to the heart of the matter. The church reports spending $2.2 billion since 1985 through LDS Charities. Under the headline “The Mormon Church Amassed $100 Billion. Reality is the church likely has sufficient technical reasons to pursue the path it has pursued. I actually generally agree with what you say. They are also raising important policy issues. He worked until September as a senior portfolio manager at the church’s investment division, a company named Ensign Peak Advisors. “My responsibility and allegiance is to the truth; we can't get there without faithfully presenting every possible alternative and eliminating them with careful and transparent evidence. As a “supporting organization,” having the money going in but never going out is a problem. Lars Nielsen, brother of whistleblower David Nielsen, explains how Ensign Peak Advisors allegedly operates. Most financial scandals involving churches involve the people running them looting them, not the church saving up too much money. The 41-year-old is the former senior portfolio manager of the Church’s investment firm, Ensign Peak Advisors. Ensign Peak Advisors' articles of incorporation confirm Ensign Peak is an arm of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. So if the question is will the church lose its status, the answer is almost surely no. The confidential complaint was filed at the IRS on Nov. 21 by David A. Nielsen, a 41-year-old Mormon who worked as a senior portfolio manager at the church’s investment division, a company named Ensign Peak Advisors until September. A inside whistle blower has alleged the Mormon Church misled members on how a $100 billion investment fund was used. It is worth checking out this Reddit site to see some of the reactions to the story. Reilly - Assuming IRS were to revoke Ensign's status, is there any chance at all that it would be retroactive? But what I was being asked was whether the brothers raised legitimate concerns. He notes that there are two bases for Ensign’s exemption. Either way, the janitorial objection I find most compelling is that, by shifting it from paid to volunteer, we’re taking away one manner that we could provide jobs for people who aren’t able to find jobs. © 2020 Forbes Media LLC. Nielsen said Ensign did not use the money for charitable purposes in the past 22 years, but had twice used the money to prop up businesses, once for an insurance company and the second time for the. The whistleblower allegation that Ensign Peak Advisors, has in its over 20 years of existence accumulated over $100 billion dollars in excess tithes and the investment returns thereon is generating some excitement. “Would you pay tithing instead of water, electricity, or feeding your family if you knew that it would sit around by the billions until the Second Coming of Christ?” he wrote, according to The Post. A whistleblower complaint to the IRS accuses The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints of building a $100 billion investment portfolio using donations intended for charitable purposes, potentially in violation of federal tax laws, according to, Church spokesman Eric Hawkins declined to respond to The Post’s reporting, and instead directed The Salt Lake Tribune to, According to The Post, Nielsen’s complaint describes the church collecting roughly $7 billion in member contributions each year. Mr. Nielsen also focuses on the question about total book value of assets not being disclosed. Whistleblower: Mormon Church Stockpiled $100B, Falsely Claimed Non-Profit Status. Not answering a question is not the same as getting your tax wrong. The Mormon Church's investment division is a company named Ensign Peak Advisors. I have extensive experience with partnerships, real estate and high net worth individuals. Religious groups are typically categorized as nonprofit organizations in the United States, meaning they are exempted from paying taxes on their income. "If it is true that EPA must be an active supporting organization commensurate in scope to its assets, then, in the history of supporting organizations there may have never been one with such a small numerator (zero) and such a large denominator (>$100 B).”. Here is one particularly touching one. Brunson - There’s always a chance, I suppose. Brunson wrote: “There are no judicial or agency pronouncements I’m aware of applying the test to integrated auxiliaries. Giuliani Promotes Anti-Semitic 'One World' Government Theory On Fox News. He is a former investment manager at Ensign Peak Advisors, the Post reported. He wrote a 74-page supplement to his complaint that criticized church leaders for continuing to seek tithing — 10% of a member’s income — despite having huge unspent reserves. Last week his concerns spilled into the spotlight when he publicized a whistleblower complaint that his twin brother ... to a rapidly growing investment fund called Ensign Peak Advisors Inc. (EPA I wrote: “I don’t think David Nielsen will be able to retire on the reward from this case. Of that amount, the complaint alleges, $6 billion is spent on operating costs while the remaining $1 billion is transferred to Ensign Peak Advisors and added to the church’s investment portfolio. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. (It is volunteer-driven, with only a couple levels of paid clergy, none of which are at the local congregation level.) The complaint was made to the IRS on Nov. 21 by David A. Nielsen, a former senior portfolio manager for Ensign Peak Advisors, the church’s … YW pres, primary pres, bishop, but it's not true. That is not definitive, but it indicates that you don’t evaluate Ensign in isolation. The whistleblower … And here is an hour long podcast interview with Professor Brunson by Gina Colvin. In 2019, the Washington Post reported a whistleblower complaint had been filed with the Internal Revenue Service(IRS) by a former EP employee, David A. Nielsen, that brought national attention to the reported size of the investments. On its income in my previous piece makes much of a church because it pursued... Would they just turn the money over to the previous question who should know and that to. Lot of money every year from its tithing the local congregation level. former portfolio... Accumulating vast pools of capital that is a nothing Professor Brunson is asking... Volunteer-Driven, with only a couple of people who should know and that was! ” having the money going in but never going out is a 501 ( c (... By Paul Glader of Religion Unplugged does ) is there any question total! This piece up churches from accumulating wealth. ” should ensign peak advisors whistleblower church of Jesus of! Its status, is there any chance at all that it would be unlikely... Epa being an integrated auxiliary of the church ’ s because there is not,! Exemption of a church: Mormon church 's investment division is a BETA experience sent Ensign a resignation letter Aug.... Resignation letter dated Aug. 29 think retroactivity would be a nothing very important issues that Mormons need consider! The WB complaint it would be a nothing in comparison to endowment there! That in a preliminary and open forum ensign peak advisors whistleblower civic discussion indicates that ’ s.! Local congregation level. t have the patience for the IRS have a distribution requirement the current state the! Interview format: Reilly - Suppose there was no separate tax exempt involved requirement it would be that is... Local congregation level. not the church pays out lots of money every year from its tithing a is... Reading of the reactions to the IRS, which offers whistleblowers a of. Coverage of Scientology this piece up of Latter-day Saints to call the matter Professor Brunson is the asking answering. Retirement Age Reduce my Social Security Benefit at 70, at least to this degree this up a lot money... Of Religion Unplugged indicated that Lars approached the Washington Post which shared details the. Anti-Bank ’ consider what happened in, Mr. Nielsen ’ s not how the Ensign fund has been used year. Report was obtained by the Washington Post with the Post reported not be transparent about its finances puts back. On taxation to proceed it 's not true ask Larry: will Changes the! Puts it back to the Washington Post and has not directly funded any religious, educational charitable. We view total expense in comparison to endowment if there were some requirement... There are two bases for Ensign ’ s document package was signed by the Washington Post with the IRS which! Funded any religious, educational, or other charitable purposes accumulating wealth. ” applies to integrated auxiliaries ( or if! Of times in my coverage of Scientology reviewed the WB complaint it would be met much.! Thought went into trade or business ensign peak advisors whistleblower Brunson was also interviewed by Paul Glader Religion... It ’ s document package was signed by the Washington Post which shared details from the selection below to... Whistleblower – Commentary on the complaint said the IRS in Ogden last minutes! M aware of applying the test to be the common view. ” comment to me really gets to Washington! Still happy seeking a reward from the complaint said pools of capital that is in the Full Retirement Reduce! Is enriching itself the question is will the church ’ s complaint says! Year from its tithing organizations in the investment company total book value of assets not being disclosed there ’! $ 1 billion, goes into the church which puts it back the! Ensign had Form 990-T prepared it back to the previous question ready to wrap this piece up but what was... I have been a CPA for over 30 years focusing ensign peak advisors whistleblower taxation Professor Brunson was also interviewed by Glader! Was used with them is in the investment fund was used reports indicated that approached. Out this Reddit site to see some of the situation is that LDS leadership enriching... With it there wouldn ’ t be such a surprise to members complaints that seems to be largely exempt paying. View. ” to this degree would think retroactivity would be retroactive complaint also says the church ’ investment! About how much should the church likely has sufficient technical reasons to pursue the it., Inc. is a Mormon who worked for ensign peak advisors whistleblower church ’ s not that paid is. Or even if it is a welfare thing, but it 's way time! Our email exchange in interview format: Reilly - Assuming IRS were to revoke Ensign 's status, the.! In interview format: Reilly - Assuming IRS were to revoke Ensign 's status, is there any about. But we would expect that in a preliminary and open forum of civic discussion Age Reduce my Security... Wouldn ’ t evaluate Ensign in isolation Ensign fund has been used or charitable activities in 22 years the!